5. Subject-Specific Prompt Banks

Calvary Preparatory Academy — Teacher Grading Examples

Holistic Grading Model — Detailed Examples & Prompts

Page 5 of 6
Subject-Specific Prompt Banks

Subject-Specific Prompt Banks

Ready-to-use questions for each subject area — organized by component. Adapt freely to the specific material your student studied.

How to use these prompts

These are starting points, not scripts. The most revealing questions are usually follow-ups to what the student just said — not questions you prepared in advance. Use these to open the conversation, then follow the student's thinking.

Mathematics

Depth of Understanding

  • Explain this concept in your own words — not from the textbook, in your own words.
  • Why does this method work? What is the underlying principle?
  • When would you use this approach versus a different one?
  • Walk me through your reasoning on this problem step by step.
  • What does this formula actually represent in real terms?
  • Can you give me a real-world situation where this math would be useful?

Responsiveness Pivots

  • Here is a problem I haven't seen you work. Walk me through it out loud.
  • What if the numbers were different — would your approach change?
  • I'm going to give you the wrong answer to this problem. Can you find my error?
  • If you couldn't use this method, what else might work?
  • Estimate the answer before you calculate it. How did you get that estimate?

Growth & Ownership

  • Which type of problem in this section was hardest for you? Why?
  • Show me a problem you got wrong. What did you misunderstand?
  • What is your specific plan for strengthening that weak area?
  • If a friend asked you to tutor them on this section, where would you start?
English & Literature

Depth of Understanding

  • What is the author trying to say in this work? What is the central argument or theme?
  • Why does this character make the choice they do? What does it reveal about them?
  • What is the most important moment in what you read? Why that one?
  • How does the author's structure reinforce the meaning — why tell it this way?
  • What evidence in the text supports your interpretation?
  • What does this work have to say about something happening in the world today?

Responsiveness Pivots

  • If this character were placed in [different situation], what would they do and why?
  • Someone argues the opposite of your interpretation — how would you respond?
  • I'm going to challenge one of your claims. Defend it.
  • What question does this text leave unanswered? Why do you think the author left it open?
  • How would this story change if it were told from a different character's perspective?

Growth & Ownership

  • What was hardest about your writing this section? Be specific.
  • Read me a sentence from your paper that you're not happy with. Why isn't it working?
  • What would you change if you rewrote this paper with a week more time?
  • What feedback from a previous paper did you apply here?
History & Social Sciences

Depth of Understanding

  • Why did this event happen? Walk me through the causes.
  • What were the consequences of this event — immediate and long-term?
  • Who had power in this situation, and how did they use it?
  • What would have had to be different for this outcome not to happen?
  • How does this event connect to something happening in the world right now?
  • What is the most important thing to understand about this period?

Responsiveness Pivots

  • Choose a different historical actor in this event. How does the story change from their perspective?
  • Make a case for the opposing interpretation of this event.
  • Apply the same forces you identified here to a current event. What do you see?
  • What is the most important question about this period that historians still debate?
  • If you had been a decision-maker in this moment, what would you have done differently?

Growth & Ownership

  • What aspect of this period did you find hardest to understand? Why?
  • What assumption did you have coming in that changed after studying this?
  • What would you want to go deeper on if you had more time?
Science

Depth of Understanding

  • Explain what happens in this process in your own words.
  • Why does this happen the way it does? What is the underlying mechanism?
  • What would change if one variable in this system were different?
  • Where do we see this principle at work in the real world?
  • Walk me through your lab procedure and what you observed.
  • What does this experiment demonstrate and why does it matter?

Responsiveness Pivots

  • Give me an example of this principle happening somewhere outside a lab.
  • What would you expect to see if we changed this variable? Why?
  • I'm going to describe a different scenario — does this principle still apply? Why or why not?
  • What would falsify this theory? What evidence would change your mind?
  • Connect this concept to something we studied three sections ago.

Growth & Ownership

  • What part of this section was most confusing? Where did you get lost?
  • If you were designing this experiment yourself, what would you do differently?
  • What question did this section raise that it didn't fully answer?
Foreign Language

Depth of Understanding

  • Read me this passage aloud.
  • Explain what this paragraph means in your own words in English.
  • Translate this sentence for me.
  • Tell me about what you did this week — in [target language].
  • Walk me through the grammar rule this section introduced.
  • What is the difference between these two structures?

Responsiveness Pivots

  • I'm going to say something in [target language] you haven't prepared — respond.
  • Describe the picture on this page in [target language].
  • Here is a sentence I haven't seen you work — translate it.
  • Make a mistake intentionally in a sentence and tell me what you did wrong.
  • Use five vocabulary words from this section in a short story. Go.

Growth & Ownership

  • Which grammar rule in this section was hardest? Why?
  • What vocabulary from this section do you feel least confident about?
  • How are you practicing outside of the textbook assignments?
Bible

Depth of Understanding

  • What is the main point of the passage you studied?
  • What does this text teach about the character of God?
  • How does this passage connect to something else in Scripture you know?
  • What did you find most challenging or surprising in what you read?
  • What is the historical or cultural context that helps explain this passage?

Responsiveness Pivots

  • How would you apply this specific principle to a decision you're facing right now?
  • Someone pushes back on this teaching — how would you respond?
  • What question does this passage raise for you that it doesn't fully answer?
  • Connect this passage to something happening in your school or community.

Growth & Ownership

  • What in this section challenged your thinking most?
  • What question are you still sitting with after studying this?
  • How is your understanding of this topic different from before you studied it?